Best ice fishing boots

11 Expertly Rugged And Best Ice Fishing Boots For MEN and WOMEN 

Ice fishing is a fun activity for friends and family during the winter months. But no one enjoys any day out if they have cold wet feet. The best ice fishing boots need to meet the highest standards for:

  • Waterproofing
  • Warmth
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Traction

Ice fishing boots need to be comfortable and safe to allow you to walk over treacherous terrain and across frozen lakes. As we all know, you reach the best ice fishing spots with some physical effort. Accordingly, some of the best ice fishing boots also serve as excellent winter hiking wear and are popular with hunters in snowy landscapes.

These qualities also mean that the best ice fishing boots make ideal extreme weather boots for everyday activities like shovelling snow or even walking around your neighborhood, especially if you live in a very cold climate.  

You don't have to go ice fishing to make buying ice fishing boots a good decision. However, if you do choose to spend some time trying to catch some naturally chilled fish, you can relax knowing that your feet will stay warm and dry with the best ice fishing boots listed below. 

This post may contain affiliate links. That means that I may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you buy something through my site. This helps me run my website and produce the articles that I hope you find helpful.

Best Ice Fishing Boots For MEN And WOMEN

How The Reviews Are Organized

I have looked at eight ice fishing boots for men and three for women. I have reviewed them for their ability to keep feet dry in wet conditions and for keeping your feet warm in subzero temperatures experienced during extreme winter weather. 

A buyer's guide follows which discusses the features that are crucial to finding the best ice fishing boots for spending a day on the ice and snow.

I have identified three fantastic ice fishing boots for women that offer everything they need. However, women may also opt to buy men's ice fishing boots because there is greater selection, are generally cheaper than women's ice fishing boots, and normally more functional with fewer fashion extras. 

Best Ice Fishing Boots For MEN

Muck Boots Woody Arctic Ice Extreme Conditions 

Pros

  • 100% waterproof neoprene – feet stay warm and dry.
  • Adjusts to your foot shape for minimal chafing
  • Thermal insulation keeps feet warm down to -60˚F
  • Excellent traction on wet and dry ice.
  • Durable
  • Easy to get on and off.

Cons

Conclusion:

Muck Boots Woody Arctic Ice Extreme Conditions Men's Winter Hunting Boot With Arctic Grip Outsole are one of the best ice fishing boots for men. 

The outer shell of 8mm thick neoprene gives a waterproof boot that fits the shape of your foot for maximum comfort when walking or trekking across any terrain. Muck Boots design their premium ice fishing boots to keep your body heat in and the cold and damp out. The neoprene shell, soft fleece lining, and the thermal foam (2mm layer) under the footbed work together to keep your toes cozy down to -60˚F (-50˚C).

The Vibram arctic grip sole with multidirectional lugs gives exceptional traction on wet and dry ice and can cope with any terrain. The combination of materials insulate, flex, and act as shock absorbers for all round durable performance. The boots aim to keep you dry, warm, and comfortable if you are walking or standing around on the ice for a long time. 

The boots are comfortable to put on and pull off. Buy them to fit your shoe size rather than a size larger unless you know that you are going to wear extra thick socks. They are available in men's shoe sizes 7 to 15 in an attractive winter forest camouflage design – bark/mobuc mini. You pay about $20 more for the larger sizes, but for a boot of this quality and durability, they are competitively priced. 

Baffin Men's Impact Insulated Boot

Pros

  • Heavy duty insulation against cold – rated to -148˚F
  • Top Toggle and buckle closures to keep out snow.
  • 8 layer removable liner.
  • Honeycomb under footbed traps air and keeps foot warmer.
  • No laces – easy to slip on and off.
  • Arctic proof rubber base.

Cons

  • Expensive compared with other boots.
  • Designed for snow and ice -he nylon and rubber construction make them waterproof but not for wading through water.

Conclusion:

Baffin Men's Impact Insulated Boots are designed for subzero temperatures and extreme snow and ice. Every feature aims at keeping your feet warm and dry. The eight layers in the lining mean that it functions as a decent inside slipper boot. The sole features a double aluminum insole and a waffle comb footbed along with polar rubber outer soles – engineered to stop cold seeping up and into your feet. 

The waffle comb structure allows the boot to wick moisture from your foot and evaporates it away. In severe arctic conditions, you don't want water on your skin. The aluminum layer is there for its reflective properties – preserving your body heat. 

These boots are favored by people routinely experiencing extreme winter conditions – dog sled racers, trekkers to the North Pole and Everest. They also serve to keep your feet incredibly warm, toasty and dry, while standing around on the ice waiting for a fish to take the bait. These boots are available from men's shoe sizes 7-14. Baffin Men's Impact Insulated Boots are some of the best ice fishing boots for men.

Guide Gear Giant Timber II Insulated Waterproof 

Pros

  • Waterproof breathable membrane keeps feet fresh and dry.
  • Comfortable down to -58˚F
  • 400g Thinsulate insulation for extra warmth.
  • Treated to kill bacteria and keep boots smelling fresh.
  • Rubber toe and heel cap for durability.
  • Padded (tongue and collar) for comfort.
  • Moderately priced

Cons

  • Non-removable liner
  • Traction but no special features to improve grip

Conclusion:

Guide Gear Giant Timber II Men's Insulated Waterproof Hunting Boots, 1,400-gram, Mossy Oak are fantastic ice fishing boots for men. They are well-insulated hunting boots that are comfortable to wear and trek across ice and snow to your best fishing spot. They are waterproof, and wick moisture away from your feet. A removable liner would be a nice feature, but with the odor control technology and the affordable price (relative to other ice fishing boots offering the same features), it is not essential. 

The upper of the Guide Gear Giant Timber II Men's Insulated Waterproof Hunting Boots is a combination of nylon and suede, and the lace fittings are sturdy and robust. The size ranges from men's shoe sizes 8 to 14, and as an added feature, the rubber soles are oil resistant. They are no-nonsense, rugged, and durable ice fishing boots that stand up to subzero temperatures in extreme winter weather.  

SOREL Men's 1964 Premium T Boots

Pros

  • Seam-sealed and waterproof
  • Comfort rated to -40˚F
  • Removable and washable inner felt liner for warmth and hygiene.
  • Rubber sole with herringbone pattern for grip and traction.
  • Attractive boots for everyday activities
  • Quality leather upper
  • Budget priced

Cons

  • Not available beyond size 13

Conclusion:

SOREL Men's 1964 Premium T Boots are a good-looking wearable boot with a full-grain leather upper bonded to a rubber sole. They are some of the best ice fishing boots on the market, but also smart enough to wear for everyday use when it is cold, snowy and slushy. In addition, they are lightweight and warm. 

The felt liner in the SOREL Men's 1964 Premium T Boots is made from recycled materials and removable for washing. The extra warm layer means these boots are comfortable down to -40˚F. The eyelets are sturdy, and the laces are a generous length.

They are not the most heavy-duty ice fishing boots available, but they would be appropriate in less frigid conditions and versatile for daily winter wear. Cost wise they are very attractive, especially in men's shoe sizes 7-11. They are available in sizes 7 through to 13 with some half sizes for additional comfort. 

Columbia Men’s Bugaboot Plus IV 

Pros

  • Non-marking sole – so you don't need to remove your boots at the door
  • Insulated (200g) to keep feet warm in subzero temperatures
  • Lightweight sole with excellent traction for rugged terrain
  • Full lace-up support for a secure fit in physically active applications
  • Rated to -25˚F
  • Available up to men's shoe size 17

Cons

  • May not be fully water-proof if submerged in water

Conclusion:

Columbia Men’s Bugaboot Plus IV Omni-Heat, Waterproof, Thermally Insulated is an attractive all round extreme winter boot that is also an excellent ice fishing boot. The leather upper is bonded to the rubber soles with an injection molded shell to produce a water-resistant boot. A trademark process allows your feet to breathe but remain dry and warm with its thermal insulation, making it comfortable down to -25˚F.

Columbia Men’s Bugaboot Plus IV Omni-Heat, Waterproof, Thermally Insulated full length lace up support and "indoor-friendly Omni-Grip" outsole makes this boot perfect in rocky terrain, deep in the snow, or crossing treacherous terrain. In addition, its lightweight midsole provides superior cushioning and long-lasting comfort.

As an extra plus, Columbia Men’s Bugaboot Plus IV are ruggedly good looking which allows them to function as an everyday boot with a floor-friendly non-marking sole. You can choose from three colours - a classic black or grey, or stylish phoenix blue. An incredible range of sizes from 7 to 17 with some half sizes means this boot should suit all feet sizes and types. Unlike some of the other ice fishing boots that made my list, you pay the same price regardless of the shoe size. The price is competitive.  

Kamik Men's Nationplus Boot

Pros

  • Thinsulate insulation
  • Rated for -40˚F
  • Antimicrobial footbed to reduce boot odor
  • Moisture-wicking to keep feet cool and dry
  • Seam-sealed and waterproof 
  • Budget friendly

Cons

  • Less insulation than other boot structures
  • Sole may not have enough padding for some

Conclusion:

Kamik Men's Nationplus Boots are affordable leather boots with a seam-sealed rubber sole. They are rated for performance to -40˚F. The lining is moisture-wicking to keep feet dry and comfortable, and this combined with an antimicrobial footbed adds additional comfort by reducing the impact of hot, sweaty feet on the boot.  

Kamik Men's Nationplus Boots are budget friendly and for the price, offers a lot of features that makes it one of the best ice fishing boots you can purchase. In addition, they are smart enough to wear for every day outdoor use and come in multiple colours. They are available in men's shoe sizes 7 to 14 with some extra wide options and half sizes.  

Vasque Men's Snowblime Ultradry 

Pros

  • Polyurethane coated leather upper for superior waterproofing
  • Waterproof membrane keeps feet dry inside the boot
  • 200g of Thinsulate insulation and gridded fleece lining for warm feet
  • Full lacing with "speed-lace" hardware at the top of the boot.

Cons

  • Hiking boot style designed for movement and not standing around

Conclusion:

Vasque Men's Snowblime Ultradry Insulated Snow Boots are ultra-dry and built like a standard hiking boot in size and shape. A solid and protective 1.8mm waterproof polyurethane coated leather upper is completed with 200mg of 3M Thinsulate insulation and a dual-density rubber sole. They supply a molded midsole cushion with mid-foot support.

Vasque Men's Snowblime Ultradry Insulated Snow Boots uses "ColdHold Technology" to give a combination sole that offers excellent traction in subzero conditions together with arch support and comfortable, flexible walking experience. The soft collar and the cozy fleece lining combine to give comfort, and avoid rubbing and irritation. They provide all metal hardware with a locking ankle hook which supplies a positive closure and a generous heel pull on loop accommodates a gloved finger. 

Available in men shoe sizes from 7 to 14 with a couple of half sizes.

Merrell Thermo Chill Waterproof Snow Boot

Pros

  • Waterproof membrane keeps feet dry.
  • 200g lightweight insulation for warmth
  • Rubber sole incorporates layers for support and comfort
  • Traditional lace-up closure with fabric laces and metal hooks for a secure fit.
  • Bellows tongue keeps debris out.
  • Pronounced lug pattern gives traction in icy conditions
  • Available in larger sizes.
  • Reasonably priced

Cons

  • Durability may be an issue depending on use

Conclusion:

Merrell Men's Thermo Chill 6" Shell Waterproof Snow Boots are waterproof sneakers that include all the snow boot technology you expect with today's winter boots. The leather has a waterproof coating, and the detailed molding of the sole provides stability, arch support, and shock absorption. 

Merrell Men's Thermo Chill 6" Shell Waterproof Snow Boots offer 200g of "Thermo Chill" insulation which provides a cozy interior to protect toes from the cold. A waterproof membrane protects the feet from dampness and slush. The kinetic fit base insole is removable and contoured to provide a comfortable walking experience. 

The 5mm lug depth provides excellent traction in snow and ice. They offer traditional lace-up closure with fabric laces and metal hooks for a secure fit. While a bellows tongue keeps debris out.

It is one of the best ice fishing boots for less frigid climates, and great for other cold weather activities, like snow shovelling, hunting, or hiking. Available sizes start at men's shoe sizes 7.5 and go up to 15. 

Best Ice Fishing Boots for Women

Baffin Women's Ice Field Insulated Boot

Pros

  • Cold rated to -148˚F
  • 100% waterproof
  • 7 Layer removable liner keeps feet warm and cozy
  • Sole and midsole molded to base for waterproof seal and excellent fit
  • Waffle comb footbed for warmth and moisture wicking
  • Arctic-quality rubber sole for extreme conditions
  • Lightweight

Cons

  • They look like storm trooper boots
  • The size range starts at 6, but they are a close fit, so women with size 4 to 5 feet and thick socks can wear them. No half sizes. 

Conclusion:

Practical ice fishing boots designed for women are hard to find. Baffin Women's Ice Field Insulated Boots are Arctic-quality women's boots and built to a similar standard as some of the best ice fishing boots for men. They will easily withstand any of winter's harsh elements with its waterproof design. Its web-lacing system and drawstring collar will keep the chill and snow out. 

Ignoring the comparisons with men's ice boots, Women's Ice Field Insulated Boots have all the technology needed to cope with extreme snow and ice. They have the right types of insulation to help withstand cold up to -148° F – reflective aluminum insoles, waffle comb construction for the footbed, insulating layers, and waterproof outside. The sole gives plenty of traction so you can walk with confidence and comfort. 

They are available in white or black, and come in women's shoe sizes 6- 11. Although they may not be high fashion, the Baffin Women's Ice Field Insulated Boots means that you can spend a day outdoors without risking frostbite. These boots are functional, durable, and if you are regularly enjoying the outdoors in frigid subzero temperatures, they are a great investment. 

Columbia Heavenly Omni-HEAT Snow Boot

Pros

  • No animal products in this snow boot
  • Waterproof and breathable
  • Non-marking soles with excellent traction
  • Well insulated and rated to -25˚F
  • Fashion details
  • Reasonably priced

Cons

  • No sizes below 5
  • May need to order a size larger than normal 

Conclusion:

Columbia Women’s Heavenly Omni-HEAT Snow Boot, Waterproof & Breathable are stylish women's snow boots which also have the technology to make them excellent ice fishing boots in severe cold weather. The outer shell is sealed to make them waterproof but also treated to be breathable. The inside lining is reflective to keep your body heat inside the boot – plus 200g of insulation to keep your toes comfortably warm. They are rated to -25˚F.

The outer rubber sole will give you excellent traction while walking around outside in snowy or icy conditions, and when you go inside, it won't mark the floors. The footbed is contoured for comfort and removable.

Columbia Women’s Heavenly Omni-HEAT Snow Boot is available in women's shoe sizes 5 to 12 with lots of half sizes, and in two colours - black and silver. It features a soft faux fur collar and tongue lining, metal rivets and lacing aglets, and a removable contoured footbed. They do not contain any animal products making it an excellent choice for those seeking an ethical option. 

The North Face Shellista II Tall

Pros

  • Waterproof with a "female" molded shell
  • Laces for a secure and adjustable fit
  • 200g thermal insulation
  • Superior winter grip and thermal sensitive lugs on sole
  • Premium materials
  • Stylish with plenty of fashion details
  • Reasonably priced

Cons

  • Not available below size 5
  • May wear out faster than normal depending on use

Conclusion:

The style and fit of the the North Face Shellista II Tall boots are gender-specific for women, starting with the injection molded shell and the fashion trims like the faux fur collar. Underneath the fancy trimmings, there is a functional cold weather boot that makes them some of the best ice fishing boots for women. The premium leather upper is fully waterproof, and 200g of quality insulation provide a dry and warm interior to keep your feet comfortable in cold, wet conditions. 

The cushioned footbed provides support where you need it, and the sole includes "TNF Winter Grip®" and "IcePick® lugs" for excellent traction when you need extra grip for balance and safe walking. These tall boots look good and perform well in severe winter conditions to keep your feet warm and dry. 

Sizes available from women's shoe sizes 5 to 11 with a multiple of color options, and the boots are competitively priced. 

Buyer's Guide To The Best Ice Fishing Boots

Ice fishing boots need to cope with the extreme challenges of keeping your feet dry and warm for a prolonged time while standing around. Plus, they need to be comfortable for walking over rough terrain and give you traction in both dry powdery snow and wet, slippery ice. 

Premier Materials For The Best Ice Fishing Boots

The best materials for a great pair of ice fishing boots must provide waterproofing, breathability, comfort, insulation, and durability. One single material does not provide all of these qualities, so most ice fishing boots use a combination of quality materials.

Leather is durable, flexible, and waterproof when correctly treated. It's a popular choice for the upper portion of the best ice fishing boots.

Rubber materials are waterproof and moldable to give a comfortable footbed and soles with plenty of texture for traction. They are normally thick to help keep cold air out. 

Neoprene is flexible and comfortable for outer shells and provides excellent thermal insulation.

Other synthetic materials supply breathable membranes, softness, thermal properties, and additional insulation.

When searching for the best ice fishing boots, consider the quality of the materials and the part they play in providing a functional as well as an attractive boot.

Stiffness For The Best Ice Fishing Boots

Achieving the right amount of waterproofing and warmth can result in a stiff, inflexible boot that is uncomfortable to wear. The preferred level of stiffness depends on the shape of the boot – a stiff hiking boot provides excellent ankle support and advantages when climbing. However, a high leg boot that is too stiff next to your calf may chafe or even make bending your knee on uneven surfaces challenging.

The degree of stiffness needed for support versus the flexibility necessary for comfortable movement varies with each individual. The only way to decide if a boot is right for you is to have the experience of wearing similar boots, so you know what combinations work for you in your preferred use. 

When it comes to the best ice fishing boots, rigid boots are typically preferable, as they are ideal for when you are planning on staying still. However, if you need to hike into an ice fishing spot, you will need to reconsider. Rubber boots are not as rigid and are designed to be more flexible. 

Outer Covering

Typically, for the best ice fishing boots, you expect a durable rubber base seam welded to a strong upper layer of waterproof coated leather or other durable material. The function of the outer coating is to keep water out.

Look for indications of proper watertight sealing where different materials join, and that coatings are waterproof rather than water-resistant. 

Insulation For The Best Ice Fishing Boots

Insulation is vital to keep your toes warm, and you need a minimum of 200g of it. However, if you are in frigid winter conditions, you should have at least 600g for a day on the ice. Most ice fishing boots will give you a comfortable temperature range for keeping your toes warm in cold conditions. 

One of the most important sources of insulation in the best ice fishing boots is "Thinsulate". The amount of Thinsulate used inside the boot should always be determined. Thinsulate is an insulation product that was developed by 3M. A key feature is its polypropylene fibers, which are stitched together inside the body of the fabric to create a strong barrier against cold.

Typically, the number of grams of Thinsulate used determines how much protection you will have from the cold. Ice fishing boots with more Thinsulate will offer more protection against the cold but will also weigh more and make the boots more inflexible.

Lower levels of insulation give a lighter, less bulky boot and make it easier to walk around. If you want to wear your ice fishing boots for other outdoor activities, such as shovelling snow, hiking or even running errands, you may need to compromise on the levels of insulation.

Cold feet make your whole body feel cold and make you feel miserable. They will ruin your day's fishing. Before purchasing, you need to figure out the likely temperatures that you will be facing so that you can determine the quality and amount of insulation that you need. 

Socks

Socks provide additional insulation, and regardless if you prefer thermal, breathable, or antibacterial socks for your feet, your ice fishing boots need enough space to accommodate them. 

The socks you team with your ice fishing boots make a real difference to your experience of a day spent ice fishing. The golden rule for warmth is to add thin layers with trapped air rather than one thick layer. Layering your socks means you can mix and match qualities like moisture-wicking and thermal insulation.

There are many different kinds of socks out there. I have written two articles about socks that may provide some assistance. Those are:

When you are trying to figure out the best socks for ice fishing boots, you may also wish to look at waterproof, heated or thermal socks. Beyond that, you should pay close attention to the material in the socks. Merino wool would be an excellent choice. They would keep your feet warm without being itchy, and they naturally wick away sweat to keep your feet cool and dry. Other synthetic fibers such as nylon, lycra and polyester should also be considered since they are key to keeping the socks' shape, and also helping with moisture. Cotton alone should be avoided as they retain moisture once wet.

Liners For The Best Ice Fishing Boots

Socks are a form of boot liner, but all boots have an inner foot-facing surface – the inner liner. Being able to remove the liner after a long day of ice fishing means you can dry it, wash it, air it out and generally make sure that the next time you put your feet in your boots, the liner is dry, clean, and odor-free. In addition, a removable liner gives you the option of rotating liners for fresher, healthier feet. 

In addition, liners offer another opportunity to add a layer of warmth to your ice fishing boots. If you think you may need more, pay attention to the material and thickness of the liner to make that determination. 

Traction

Rubber soles give a sticky contact with the ground, but you need intelligent lug design to provide you with traction on the different types of surfaces you encounter while ice fishing – snow, dry ice, wet ice, and slushy or rocky terrain. 

Sole technology focuses on the design of the lugs and innovative use of materials. As well as looking for boots with the best technology for traction, think about using spikes for extra safety.

Laces For The Best Ice Fishing Boots

Laces are flexible because they allow you to adjust the fit of the boots for thicker socks, hiking up slopes, or any other change that needs you to flex the fit of your boots.  Zips, by comparison, are inflexible. 

Lacing arrangements depend on robust, securely mounted eyelets. If you know you need to get in and out of your boots rapidly, look for speed lacing fittings similar to those on hiking boots. In addition, quality laces should be thick enough to be easy to grip while wearing gloves and not easily tear apart.

Conclusion

The best ice fishing boots keep your feet comfortable in extreme weather conditions. Happy feet keep a smile on your face, so it is worth investing time, money and effort to determine the best ice fishing boots for you. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the warmest ice fishing boots?

Baffin Men’s Impact Insulated boots and Baffin Women’s Ice Field Insulated boots are the warmest ice fishing boots. They are each rated to -148˚F; 100% waterproof; have at least 7 layers of removable liners; have soles and midsoles molded to their base for a waterproof seal; includes waffle comb footbeds for warmth and moisture-wicking; and Arctic-quality rubber sole for extreme conditions.